Thrifty Finds: Pottery Treasures Sought by Collectors

the-rare-&-valuable-vintage-pottery-brand-collectors-always-look-for-at-the-thrift-store

Thrifting is such a fun way to spend a Saturday. Browsing the shelves for hidden gems and sifting through racks of retro clothes to find your next party look is so relaxing. But sometimes, the stuff you come across at thrift stores can actually be super valuable and have a really interesting history behind it. When it comes to pottery, one find that thrifters dream of is pieces made by the McCartys. This brand’s story goes back to the 1950s, when Lee and Pup McCarty took a pottery class and discovered a new passion. At the time, they lived in Oxford, Mississippi and got to know the writer William Faulkner, who let them dig clay from his land for their projects.

After setting up a pottery studio in a mule barn in Lee’s hometown of Merigold, Lee and Pup spent years pouring their hearts and stories into their creations. They did everything themselves, from digging the clay to adding the final glaze. McCarty pottery is defined by its quality and the love between this married couple who worked side-by-side for decades.

McCarty pieces have made their way around the world, with items on display in Japan, Germany, and Paris. If you happen to spot a McCarty at a thrift store, you could be looking at a real score. Smaller, more common pieces can sell for $100-$200. But rare finds have gone for around $10,000 at auctions.

How to spot McCarty pottery

When you’re pottery hunting at the thrift store, keep an eye out for a few key things. McCarty pottery includes vases, plates, bowls, and all sorts of sculpted animal figurines – things like rabbits, fish, and even hippos. A trademark McCarty design is a small, wiggly black line that represents the Mississippi River, where their clay came from. Many pieces also have Lee and Pup’s hand-signed signatures. The colors are something to watch for too – classic McCarty shades include cobalt blue, jade, and a nutmeg brown that Pup created by mixing in coffee grounds.

If you do stumble upon McCarty pottery at the thrift store, you could sell it for a nice profit. Or, you might want to keep it, display it proudly, and treasure a piece of history. In a world of mass-produced, low-quality stuff, McCarty’s creations represent a time when people took the time to craft things with care and put their heart into their work.